What happens to your creativity in the moment between “I could do that” and “Who am I kidding?”

When I was a junior at UConn, I walked into a career fair with a stack of freshly printed résumés and found exactly one company hiring civil engineers. I was crushed. Then a thought popped into my head. “What if I started a career fair just for civil engineering students?”

I didn’t think of that as creativity at the time. I was looking up companies in the Yellow Pages and mailing letters. But years later, when I told that story at a writing workshop, I heard it differently. I was just beginning to recognize that quiet voice in my life, and I thought, “Oh, that was her, too.” She’d been there all along.

That’s part of why I wanted to spend one more episode with Genesis 1:1. “In the beginning, God created the heavens and the earth.” Now when I hear those words, I find myself asking when something really begins. Is it when you first hear the idea, or when you give it a form somebody else can see? And what happens to you in the space between those two moments?

In Episode 19 of Know Thy Soul, I follow that question from a college career fair to Hamilton, a copy of Big Magic I bought on a whim, and the choices that have made the life I’m living feel more like mine.

If there’s an idea you keep coming back to, I’d love for you to listen with that idea in mind.


Listen on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Youtube or your favorite streaming platform, or click below:

 

 

 

 

Mentioned in this episode:

  • Episode 18 of Know Thy Soul on Genesis 1:1 and the opening Hebrew words Bereshit bara
  • The Zohar and its reading of Bereshit as “with wisdom”
  • Proverbs 8 and the figure of Wisdom
  • Merriam-Webster’s definition of “create,” which uses Genesis 1:1 as an example
  • Lin-Manuel Miranda’s Hamilton and Ron Chernow’s biography Alexander Hamilton
  • Moana, with a brief aside about why I see echoes of Genesis in it
  • Elizabeth Gilbert’s Big Magic and her earlier memoir Eat, Pray, Love
  • The Gospel of Thomas, saying 70, on bringing forth what’s within us
  • Angela Duckworth’s research on grit, which she and her colleagues define as perseverance and passion for long-term goals
  • Perceval and the Handless Maiden, stories we’ve explored in earlier episodes of Know Thy Soul
  • Episode 8 of Know Thy Soul, where I share some of the ways I’ve learned to listen to my inner knowing

🌙 Learn more, explore additional resources, and join the Know Thy Soul community at:

https://knowthysoul.com

 🎙️New episodes every Tuesday.


Prefer to read?

The full episode transcript is below.


Hi, friends.

Welcome to Know Thy Soul, where we explore the stories and symbols that help us reconnect with the wisdom and creativity already living within us.

Last week we spent fifty minutes on the very first verse of Genesis. “In the beginning, God created the heavens and the earth.” Fifty minutes on one verse, and we barely scratched the surface.

Before we move on, I want to stay with that verse for one more week, because it got me thinking about how things begin in our own lives.

Have you ever had an idea you could feel so clearly, and then talked yourself out of it before you’d even given it a chance? Or maybe you tried to explain it to somebody, and halfway through you realized they couldn’t see what you were seeing?

That idea can feel to you in either of those moments. You can picture it so clearly, even though there’s nothing you can point to yet and say, “Here. This is what I mean.” So when did it actually begin? Was it when you first pictured it, or when it took on a form somebody else could see?

That’s the question that sent me back to the first two words of Genesis. So let’s start with the first one again. Bereshit is what we hear as “in the beginning.” And the Hebrew word for “beginning,” reshit, is feminine.

The Zohar, a Jewish mystical text, hears another layer in that opening word. It reads it as “with wisdom.” And remember how, in Proverbs, Wisdom speaks as a woman who was there with God before the earth took shape?

The Zohar also sees the letters of bara, the word for “created” that comes next, tucked inside Bereshit. So there’s this little echo right at the beginning of the story. And the way I read it, creation happens twice. It begins in the inner world, the unseen, spiritual world, when an idea first starts to take shape within us. And it begins again when we give that idea a form in the physical world, where someone else can see it or hear it or touch it.

Do you remember how I’ve been saying, as we’ve gone through these stories, that the feminine is the queen of the inner world and the masculine is the king of the outer world? Well, we’re two words into the Bible, and I can already see that pattern starting to take shape.

And today I want to see if we can recognize it in something we’ve made ourselves, I want to tell you a story about when I was in college.

I was a junior at UConn when I went to the school-wide career fair. I remember walking across campus with this portfolio full of résumés I’d just printed. Do you remember that special parchment paper we used to use? I remember feeling like such an adult buying that. I was so excited. I felt like my future was waiting for me on the other side of those doors.

When I walked in, somebody handed me a flyer with a matrix showing all the companies at the fair and which majors they hired from. So I scanned down the page until I found civil engineering, then ran my finger across the row to see who was there.

One company. At the whole career fair, there was one company hiring civil engineers. And it wasn’t even a company I could see myself working for. I remember standing there with all those résumés thinking, “Wait, that’s it?”

I was crushed. I’d walked all the way across campus picturing who I might meet, I’d spent days creating a resume and I’d barely made it through the door. And then, almost as quickly as the disappointment hit, I had this thought. “What if I started a career fair just for civil engineering students?”

Now, let’s stop right there for a second. That tiny sentence, “I should start a career fair just for civil engineers.” That’s what I mean by wisdom here. There was no career fair yet. There was just this one sentence, and already something had begun.

It makes me think of that oversized first Bet in Genesis. When I tell this story, this is as far back as I can go. I can tell you what I did once the idea showed up, but where did it come from? My brain? Was it floating around in the ether waiting for somebody to grab it? Did it come from my soul? God? The civil engineering gods? The truth is, we’ll never know. But that’s where the story starts for me.

And how often do we have a thought like that and shut it down in the very next breath? We tell ourselves, “Who am I to do that? I don’t have the skills. I’m not qualified.” And if you remember the Handless Maiden, that’s what I picture when we do this. We cut off the idea’s hands before it’s had a chance to do anything in the world.

But I was young, I was tenacious, and honestly, I think this idea had wings before it even got to me. So here’s what I did.

I was already elected to be the President of the civil engineering society for my senior year. So I pitched it to Dean at our next board meeting. And do you know what the Dean said? He said “oh, that’s cute Jenn, you’ll probably get 5 or 6 companies.”

But it didn’t stop me. Did I know that there was a solid post job market economy for freshly graduated students? No clue. Did I know of even one company hiring? Nope. Did I have any idea what I was doing? Again, no.

But something inside me knew and it drove me forward. So I took it one step at a time. I found a venue on campus, I wrote a letter inviting companies to come, I searched the yellow pages for said companies to invite, I sent the letters, and then, I waited.

What the dean thought would only be 5 or 6 companies turned out to be almost 25 companies. The day was a huge success.

Did I get a job from that career fair? Nope. Did I ever get recognized for it? Or paid for it? Nope, and nope again.

But that fair was my baby. I made sure the president the following year knew everything I had done and everything I would have changed to make it better. And I followed the fair for a few years, always feeling a sense of pride when I would see it pop up on the civil engineering departments website.

But life happened and I lost track of that fair.

But a few years ago, I was guided to tell that story for a workshop I was teaching, and I got excited to look it up again on the website. At this point, it had been over 20 years since I first started it.

And I was devastated to not see any mention of it anywhere. But that little voice nudged me to pick up the phone and call the department. And by this time, I’m a loyal follower of that voice, so when they picked up, I said “Hi, my name’s Jenn, this is kind of a random call but I graduated in 2001 and I was the one who started that civil engineering career fair many years ago. I noticed it was no longer on the website and I was just curious what happened to it?”

And she said, “Oh, that. A few years ago, the School of Engineering saw what a good idea it was, so they took it over and opened it up to all the engineering departments.”

You guys. Oh my gosh. I wish I could explain what that moment felt like. My little baby idea was still around, twenty-plus years later. And it had grown into something bigger than I’d ever pictured when I first thought, “I should start a career fair just for civil engineers.”

I’ll never get paid for that, and most of the people who go to that career fair will probably never know I started it. And what surprised me in that moment was how little I cared about any of that. I was just so happy it was still there. Maybe it helped a student meet somebody they wouldn’t have met otherwise. Maybe it made it a little easier for a company to find the engineer they were looking for. I’d gone on with my life, and this little thing I started was still doing something for somebody.

And you know, if you’d asked me back then whether I was doing something creative, I probably would’ve said, “I’m putting together a career fair.” When I heard the word creative, I pictured somebody painting or making a sculpture. I was looking up companies in the Yellow Pages and writing letters.

But there was a moment when I stood there with that flyer in my hand and pictured a career fair that didn’t exist yet. And when I look back now, that’s the part I’m curious about. How often do we do something like that and never think to call it creativity?

In fact, I looked up the word create on Merriam-Webster, and it means “to bring into existence.” And do you know what example they use? Genesis 1:1 “God created the heaven and the earth.” I laughed when I saw that. Of course that’s the example.

So when I talk about creativity, I’m talking about giving something you can see on the inside a form in the world. That could be a song or a book. It could also be a career fair. And as I learned with my dean, there’s a good chance the first person you tell won’t be able to picture it the way you do.

Can you imagine being in the room when Lin-Manuel Miranda stood up at the White House and said he was working on a hip-hop album about Alexander Hamilton? People laughed. And I get it. If all you know about Alexander Hamilton is that he’s the guy on the ten-dollar bill, that’s a pretty big leap.

And then he performed the song. You can look it up on YouTube. It opened in Aaron Burr’s voice, and it would eventually become the opening number of Hamilton. Six years later, that hip-hop album idea had become a Broadway musical. It went on to win eleven Tonys.

And where did it begin? He was on vacation reading a biography of Alexander Hamilton. He told the author, Ron Chernow, that as he read, he could hear hip-hop songs rising off the page. I love that image. How many people had read those same pages? And this is what he heard.

There’s something about Hamilton that I still have trouble putting into words. I can tell you what I love about the music, and I can point to a line and tell you why I think it’s brilliant. But when I listen to it, I feel something I can’t quite name. I think Lin-Manuel tapped into something in that other realm, in the unseen world we’ve been talking about. And somehow, when we hear the music or see the show, we get to feel a little of what he touched.

And don’t even get me started on Moana. I see Genesis all over that movie. But that’s another story for another day. Maybe after we finish the creation story, which, at the rate we’re going, could be a while.

This is what I mean when I say we’re the bridge between heaven and earth. Lin-Manuel heard something while he was reading a book, and he worked with what he heard until he could sing it to somebody else. And now there’s a whole theater full of people feeling something that began in a moment only he could tell us about.

When I started thinking about writing, I wanted to learn from people who were already doing it. I think of those knotted branches in Perceval. Somebody’s been down this path before you, and sometimes they’ve left you something to follow.

About six years ago, I was thinking about starting a blog. One day I went into Barnes & Noble looking for a gift for somebody else, and there was Big Magic by Elizabeth Gilbert, sitting on one of those display tables. It almost felt like it was glowing. I knew her from Eat, Pray, Love, but I’d never heard of this book. And I don’t know how else to say it. It felt like the book was calling to me.

Now, back then, I never bought a book on the fly. I’d read the description, look up the reviews, and somehow turn buying one book into a whole research project. But that day I picked it up, bought it, and read it in twenty-four hours. And I’ve gone back and read it several times since.

In Big Magic, Gilbert imagines that an idea might be out there looking for somebody to help bring it into the world. Remember when I wondered if the career fair idea was just floating around somewhere until it found me? When I read her description, I thought, “Oh, I know that feeling.” I’d always called it divine inspiration.

And I wonder how often something catches our attention like that and we’re already halfway into explaining it away. I could’ve looked up the reviews like I always did. That day, I was curious enough to see what would happen if I just took the book home.

The more I listened to creative people talk about their work, and the more I studied different spiritual traditions, the more my understanding of creativity changed.

I used to think some people just had a creative gene. Now that I’ve felt this in my own life, I know what it’s like to hear an idea and give it a form. And I know how quickly I can cut its hands off. I hear a little nudge, and before I’ve even given it a chance, I’m asking, “Does that make sense? Am I qualified? What would people think?”

And sometimes I put on a little armor, too. I tell myself I’m just being practical, or I need to do a little more research. I mean, look how much thinking I could do over buying one book. After a while, I can get so used to talking myself out of these little things that I barely notice the nudge in the first place.

That’s what I think of when somebody says, “I’m just not creative.” I wonder what they used to get curious about before they started deciding whether they were any good at it. And that brings me back to those first two words of Genesis. I recognize that movement now. Something begins quietly inside us, and we get to take part in giving it a form out here.

There’s a saying in the Gospel of Thomas where Jesus says, “If you bring forth what is within you, what you bring forth will save you.” And then he says that what we leave unexpressed can destroy us. I think he’s pointing to something much bigger than creativity. But I do think creativity is part of it. What happens to us when we keep hearing something inside and keep telling ourselves it isn’t worth bringing into the world?

And this is where I come back to Bereshit bara. In the way I’m reading Genesis, earth is where something that begins in the unseen takes on a physical form. And I see that same movement when we create.

And, spoiler alert, a little later in this story, human beings are made in the image and likeness of God. Think about what we’ve seen God doing from the very first verse. God is creating. So when I hear that we’re made in God’s image, I wonder if part of what that means is that we were created to be creators, too.

Think about Lin-Manuel reading that history book. The feminine in him can hear a song in those pages. The masculine in him can sit down and work out how it goes, line by line, until there’s a song he can sing and someone else can hear. And I wonder how much of what we’re here to create begins in a moment that ordinary.

And this brings me back to that little detail we noticed last week, where heaven and earth seemed to mirror each other right there in the Hebrew. If you add up the numerical values of the letters in et ha-shamayim, “the heavens,” you get 796. Do the same with et ha-eretz, “the earth,” and you get 697. 7-9-6. 6-9-7. The same digits, in reverse.

And when I think about the success of Hamilton, I think about what happens to the people who hear it. A song can bring somebody joy. It can make them curious about a piece of history they never cared about before. It can give them words for something they’ve felt in their own life. I think there’s something beautiful about using the gifts God gave you to make something another person can carry with them.

So you may be thinking, if this creative force is in all of us, why is it so hard to bring some of the things we imagine into the world? And if you’ve been with me for a few episodes, you know we keep coming back to that in the stories. It can be hard to hear what’s stirring in us in the first place. And even when we do hear it, we still have to figure out how to stay with it long enough to make something.

That’s where I think of the psychologist Angela Duckworth. She and her colleagues studied people in all sorts of settings, from cadets at West Point to kids in the National Spelling Bee. And one quality that helped predict how people did was something she called grit. She defines it as “perseverance and passion for long-term goals.”

I like that she puts passion and perseverance together. Think about something you were excited to start. On the first day, you might have so much energy you don’t even want to stop for dinner. Then there’s a Tuesday a month later when you’ve got twenty minutes and you’re still trying to get the same paragraph right. Grit is caring about what you’re making enough to come back to that paragraph, even on a day when writing it feels like work.

And when I think about Bereshit bara, I think about how much of creation happens on those ordinary Tuesdays. There’s the moment you hear the idea, and there’s the moment somebody else gets to hear what you made. In between, there are all these little moments when you sit back down and see what you can do with it today.

And when I think about grit in my own life, I think about this podcast. I don’t know where it’s going to take me, if anywhere. I don’t have a lot of the things the outer world points to when it calls something successful. But every week, I feel moved to sit down and make another episode. And I’ve been thinking about what keeps bringing me back to the microphone.

For me, grit is tied to a connection with something deeper within myself. I feel like I’m connected to a creative force that was there long before I ever thought about starting a podcast. And I feel that connection when I’m sitting with a story I’ve read a dozen times and suddenly a line opens up in a way it never has before. I start to see a story beneath the story I thought I knew. I show up so I can ask, ‘Do you hear that, too?’

I don’t know if this podcast will grow into anything. But there’s already something I get from making it that’s harder to measure. I get to spend time with questions that matter to me, and sometimes, in trying to put words to what I’m hearing, I discover something about my own life that I couldn’t see before. I can think of one morning in particular when that happened.

Back in episode eight, I shared a few ways I’ve learned to listen to that inner knowing. And you might remember that a few years ago, at a writing workshop, I was invited to get up on stage and give a three-minute presentation. The next morning, I heard something so clearly inside me, that the idea I’d pitched in those three minutes would be the premise of my first book.

And do you know what story I told on that stage? I told the story of the career fair.

I’d told that story plenty of times over the years, because, as it turns out, that’s also where I met my now ex-husband. But around the time of that workshop, I was just beginning to recognize that quiet voice in my life. So I sat in stillness and asked, “What do I have to say about creativity?” And she told me to tell the story of the fair.

And for the first time in almost twenty years, I heard that story a little differently. I thought about standing there with that flyer in my hand and hearing those words, “You should start a career fair.” And I thought, “Oh, that was her, too.” I was only just learning to recognize her, and she’d been there all along.

Here I am, twenty-five years after I had that idea, and I’m still learning from it. Telling that story at a writing workshop helped me see what my first book could be. And now I’m telling it to you because it’s helping me see something in the first line of Genesis.

It also brings me back to those words from the Gospel of Thomas about bringing forth what’s within us. Sometimes that means taking an idea and making something other people can be part of. And sometimes it means letting what you know deep down change the way you live. Those two things can ask something very different of you. At least they did for me.

Because even while I was planning a career fair for civil engineers, I could hear that same voice telling me civil engineering was the wrong major for me. I thought about getting a master’s in architecture. I even thought about transferring schools. I could hear her clearly enough to imagine a different life, and I still stayed. I knew to listen to her when it came to planning an event. Changing the direction of my own life was something I was still learning how to do.

And when I think about the Handless Maiden growing her hands back, I think about how long that took me. Little by little, I learned to take what I knew inside seriously enough to make a different choice on the outside. Sometimes that meant starting something, like the fair. Years later, it meant leaving my marriage. And in both cases, that’s what bringing forth what was within me looked like. It changed what I did next.

And here’s something I can only see looking back. I knew even then that civil engineering wasn’t where I wanted to spend my life. And yet, do you hear how I take apart a verse? I look at one word, then I look at the word beside it, and I ask, “Okay, if I’m reading it this way, does that still make sense when I get to the next line?” It’s a little like working through a proof.

I used to do something similar when I drew site plans. I’d have the drawing in front of me and the local codes and ordinances beside it. If I moved something on the plan, I’d have to go back and see what else that changed. And I do a version of that when I read Genesis. If I hear a new possibility in the first word, I want to see how it holds up when I read the rest of the verse, and what happens when I get to the next one. I learned to think that way in engineering, and here I am using it to read a creation story.

And it was in my marriage that I began to see how often I’d been abandoning what I knew inside. That’s how I came to recognize myself in the Handless Maiden, and why growing my hands back means something so personal to me. And now, when I sit down to make an episode, I bring both of those things with me. I bring the way I learned to think, and I bring what it felt like to live through some of the things I can see in these stories. I never would’ve guessed those parts of my life would have anything to do with each other.

And I keep coming back to what Jesus says in the Gospel of Thomas. “If you bring forth what is within you, what you bring forth will save you.” I think I understand that a little better now. When I told the story of the career fair at that workshop, I heard my own life differently. I recognized a voice I was just learning to listen to, and I realized she’d been there all along. And the more I listen to her, the more the life I’m living on the outside feels like mine.

I think that’s one way creativity can save us. Sometimes bringing forth what’s within me looks like starting a career fair or sitting down to make a podcast. Sometimes it looks like making a choice I’ve known deep down for a long time I needed to make. And every time I take what I hear inside seriously enough to do something with it, I come a little closer to being myself.

Twenty-five years ago, all I had was one sentence about a career fair. Now I sit down every week and make an episode because there’s something in a story I want to understand and talk through with you. Maybe twenty years from now I’ll look back at what I’m making today and think, “Oh, that’s where that began, too.” I just can’t see it yet.

So I’ll leave you with this. Is there an idea that keeps coming back to you? What might you find out about yourself if you gave it a little room in your life?

Until next time, my friends, may you know thy soul. It already knows the way.

 

 

Related episodes